[Red5] more buffering problems

[Steven Gong]

Thanks Dan for your comparison. It would be better if you report this on
Trac so that this great stuff won't be forgotten. :-)

The main problem for us now is the lack of test clients. For example, a test
client for testing buffer issues. Any contribution is welcomed.

On 8/29/06, Dan Rossi <spam at electroteque.org> wrote:
>
>  hi, i spent quite a while doing some buffering comparisons with FMS2. I
> was using both a 180k and 300k video, im on a 512k connection, and i was
> connecting to a dell server in our office in sydney and our server in NY.  I
> ran tests on a 10 and 2 second buffer.
>
> I still feel there is some major buffering problems, and any advice to
> rectify it would be great, VOD streams better than live streaming aswell
> which i cant even stream properly yet. let me know thanks.
>
> *Office Server:*
>
> *10 Second buffer*
>
> red5 with / without buffer configure
>
> 108 goes down to 2 then increases again
> 144 30 sec buffer
> maintains good buffer
> 298 sec, lots of movement rebuffers
>
>
> fms:
>
> 100 secs 50 sec buffer
> 200 secs 50 sec buffer
> maintains buffer throughout
>
> *
> 2 Second Buffer
>
> *red5
>
> 30 secs 5 sec buffer
> 75 secs rebuffers
> 84 rebuffers
> doesnt retain buffer
>
> fms
>
> 30 secs 8 sec buffer
> 50 secs 15 sec buffer
> 70 secs degrades down to 10
> ramps up again to 20
> continues to incrase and decrase between 10 and 20
>
>
>
> *Remote Server:*
>
> *10 second buffer*
>
>
> 180k
>
> *red5*
>
> 41 sec rebuffer
> 82 secs rebuffer
> 186 sec rebuffer
>
> *fms*
>
> buffers fine, keeps increasing.
>
>
> 300k
> *
> red5 with/wihtout buffer configurer*
>
> 36 rebuffer
> 69 rebuffer
> 103 rebuffer
>
> *
> fms:*
>
> 74 seconds rebuffer
> 180 peaks at 18 sec buffer
> 200 10 sec buffer
> 240 rebuffer
> 279 rebuffer
>
>
> *2 Second Buffer*
> *
> red5
>
> *2 sec buffer constantly rebuffers
>
>
> *fms *
>
> rebuffers 42 secs
> doesnt retain buffer
>
> 180k
>
> *red5*
>
> 10 secs rebuffer
> 20 secs rebuffer
> 60 secs 10 sec buffer
>
> *fms*
> retains buffer
>
> _______________________________________________
> Red5 mailing list
> Red5 at osflash.org
> http://osflash.org/mailman/listinfo/red5_osflash.org
>
>
>


-- 
Best Regards
Steven Gong
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://osflash.org/pipermail/red5_osflash.org/attachments/20060829/9bf1f97f/attachment.htm